Dennis Cramer’s 2011 list of wrong doctrines...
DOCTRINES OF CONCERN
• OPEN THEISM: Teaches that God does not always know the outcome of earthly events when man is involved – that man can actually catch God “off guard”, surprise Him, and alter His will. For example, it teaches that God did not know Adam was going to sin. Yet there are numerous verses that clearly teach God is sovereign and knew exactly what was going to happen and when it was going to happen. If God did not know that Adam was going to sin, then why was the Lamb slain from before the foundations of the world? (I Pe.1:18-20) Additional proof texts: Eph.1:4, Ps.139.4, Ps.139:16, Is.46:10, Ecc. 3:11, I Jn. 3:20, Jn. 21:17. If God is not omniscient, then He is not sovereign. If He is not sovereign, then He is not God. God is all-knowing: past, present, and future. Open theism is a dangerous teaching that under- mines the sovereignty, majesty, infinitude, knowledge, existence, and glory of God and exalts the nature and condition of man’s own free will. A god of open theism is not as knowledgeable or as ever-present as the true God of the bible.
• ULTIMATE RECONCILIATION: Teaches that hell will one day be emptied, that all of mankind (saved and unsaved) will live together eternally in heaven regardless of their actions while they lived on earth. This is an old heresy that pops up every fifty years or so. There is no biblical basis for this very dangerous doctrine.
• THE “NEFILIN” CHILDREN ALIVE ON EARTH: Teaches that there are currently living beings on the earth who are the distant offspring of the original “giants” conceived by angels and women mentioned in the book of Genesis. This is pure speculation. Recent books on the subject have caught our attention, but this topic was never supposed to be a major bible doctrine. Some authors have taken extreme liberty and license to write about it. Again, it is pure speculation and could serve as a distraction from more important issues in the church.
• OPEN HEAVEN: Teaches that we as Christians should be asking God to “rend the heavens” and open them to us so we could experience God’s power and presence. Actually, this is totally unnecessary since God, through Jesus Christ, has already fully opened the heavens to each and every believer. Every believer has been walking under the “open heaven” atmosphere from the moment they were born again. Hebrews calls it the “throne of Grace” (Heb.4:16). This “throne of grace” in heaven is already open and available, 24/7, to all believers who access it in the name of Jesus. How? By faith.
• THIRD HEAVEN EXPERIENCES AT WILL: Do I believe in third heaven experiences? Absolutely, I do. The bible supports such sovereign experiences as in the example of Paul in II Cor.12. Do I believe in being physically transported? Absolutely, I do! By a sovereign act of God, Phillip was physically transported (Acts 8) from one location to another. So if it’s in the bible I believe it! I believe it all! Amen!
However, there is a HUGE difference between God willing you to have a certain sovereign bible experience, (like Paul or Phillip) as opposed to you willing it, or trying to make it happen, to duplicate it through mere human effort or merely through the exercising of your human or soulish will, in other words, “at will.” These bible experiences were 100% sovereign. They did not happen because these individuals willed them into existence or willed them to happen. God and God alone initiated them – He and He alone willed them. This is the very nature of a sovereign experience: God makes it happen when He wants, where he wants, and with whom He wants. Period! And they usually happened when the candidates or recipients least expected it. Why? Because these were sovereign events, not planned or initiated by man, but by God.
• GOING TO HEAVEN AT WILL TO GET YOUR GIFTS: There is no biblical record of any believer having to go to heaven to get any gift. This is a totally unnecessary spiritual exercise. The three listings of gifts in Romans, I Cor., and Ephesians have all been in the church for over two thousand years. They are not in heaven, so why go there to get them? The Father, Son, and Holy Spirit have each deposited Their respective gifts in the church here on earth. For 2000 years, Christians have been receiving here ON EARTH from this great deposit of gifts. “Thy kingdom come, Thy will be done, ON EARTH, as it is in heaven.” Amen!
• CLOUD OF WITNESSES / DEAD SAINTS: Teaches that Christians should expect the intervention of dead saints in our daily lives. This entire deception is based on a terribly irresponsible interpretation of a single obscure verse in Hebrews 12:1. We do not need dead saints intervening in our lives. We have Jesus as our Mediator, the ONLY mediator we need between God and man (I Tim.2:5) and He is not dead. He is alive! Necromancy, that is, communication with the dead, (any dead) is forbidden in scripture.
• TRAVELING IN TIME AT WILL: I have been unable to find this in the bible. Let alone doing it “at will.”
• TRANSPORTING PHYSICALLY AT WILL: See Third Heaven experiences above...
• OVER EMPHASIS ON ANGELS: Yes, they are real. But an angelic visitation is a rare and precious event. Most Christians will never have an encounter with one. And it is extremely unlikely that a Christian will be visited by an arc angel. Michael and Gabriel were given specific, significant, world changing tasks in the scriptures. It is likely that they have more important things to do than to drop by your house for a visit!
• GOING INTO TRANCES AT WILL:
See comment re. “self-willed” and God’s sovereign will at the end f the list of questionable doctrines.
• TRANCE DANCING: I have been unable to find this in the bible.
• GOING TO HELL TO DISCERN EVIL SPIRITS IN ORDER TO DELIVER SOMEONE: No one in the bible ever had to go to hell to discern a spirit. Why should we?
• HYPER-GRACE: CHRISTIANS DO NOT NEED TO REPENT OF SIN. The only biblical response for sin is ALWAYS repentance for both the sinner and the saved. How else can a believer be accountable for his sin except to repent of it? No form of grace removes the believer’s responsibility to repent for his sin.
• QUICK RESTORATION OF FALLEN CHURCH LEADERS: Why should a fallen leader necessarily be restored back to his ministry, especially after numerous failures over the space of years? Sometimes fallen leaders should not be restored back to ministry at all, but back to finding a secular job, loving their spouse, and raising their kids. However, if it is decided that a fallen leader be restored back to his ministry, I am not against restoring that leader. I am however against restoring that leader too quickly.
• DIVORCE AMONG CHRISTIANS WITHOUT CONSEQUENCES: All of us are aware of the terrible increase of divorce among Christians. Yet, what troubles me more is the lack of consequences from these divorces. Covenant is very important to God. Divorce is not God’s best. Breaking the marriage covenant is a serious issue. Yet many Christians, and even ministers, never miss a step. One day they divorce, and soon after they are back in the pulpit and/or often in a new marriage.
• THE BIBLE CONTAINS CULTURAL AND GENDER BIASES: No, it does not! I’ve actually been told by pastors that they have made decisions to counter the various biases that they perceive in the bible. I was stunned! How can the bible be inerrant, infallible, and contain biases and/or prejudices at the same time? It cannot! But some preach this from their pulpits, misrepresenting God’s word, the bible.
Dennis Cramer’s note and comment on “self-will” and the sovereign will of God...
The question of supernatural sovereign experiences “at will”
Do I believe in third heaven experiences? Absolutely, I do. The bible supports such sovereign experiences as in the example of Paul in II Cor.12. Do I believe in being physically transported? Absolutely, I do! By a sovereign act of God, Phillip was physically transported (Acts 8) from one location to another. So if it’s in the bible I believe it! I believe it all! Amen!
However, there is a HUGE difference between God willing you to have a certain sovereign bible experience, (like Paul or Phillip) as opposed to you willing it, or trying to make it happen, to duplicate it through mere human effort or merely through the exercising of your human or soulish will, in other words, “at will.” These bible experiences were 100% sovereign. They did not happen because these individuals willed them into existence or willed them to happen. God and God alone initiated them – He and He alone willed them. This is the very nature of a sovereign experience: God makes it happen when He wants, where he wants, and with whom He wants. Period! And they usually happened when the candidates or recipients least expected it. Why? Because these were sovereign events, not planned or initiated by man, but by God.
When discussing a sovereign experience there is a big difference between initiating versus cooperating. God INITIATES all sovereign experiences, the believer COOPERATES with them. Mix the two, crisscross them, and this can lead to some real doctrinal confusion and counter-productive measures.
|
posted Jan 4, 2012 9:59 AM by Bill Lewis
[
updated Jan 4, 2012 9:59 AM
]
I just started reading another book by Tom Brokaw. My brother gave me this one for Christmas. I had read his book, The Greatest Generation, a few years ago. In The Greatest Generation, he chronicles the stories of the World War II generation which is fast leaving the earth. So, he wanted their stories told, his father’s and mine’s generation.
In this book, The Time of Our Lives, he begins to explore the ideas which have changed rapidly and asks poignant questions regarding our country and our culture. Such questions as, “Have we lost our way?” And, “Who are we now as a nation?”
As I was reading the preface and the introductory questions were being asked, I thought to myself that the church and Christianity ought to be asking the same questions. One of the real questions for thought is the technological breakthroughs and inventions and how cyberspace is changing us, in fact, dramatically.
We are radically changing the way life is lived. When I first saw “texting” being advertised for cell phones, I thought, “Why text when you could just call?” But, it caught on and now we live in a texting world. We gave up writing letters and started using e-mail and now we have given up talking for texting.
What is amazing is that you can make a call to a person, particularly younger ones, and get no response. But, if in the next minute, you text; you will get a reply shortly. I think it has come to the place that we do not want to talk. The culture has dismissed civility and dispensed with the hello’s and how are you’s to cut directly to the terse point and counter point. We have further reduced the joy of the language to cryptic phonics to convey our message in as few key strokes or taps as possible. Yet, the communication has increased to the point that no one in the room is really connected to the folks in front of them; they are connected to anyone who texts them from anywhere in the world.
The ubiquitous smartphone lives in the hands of people. I know some that never put it down. They nap with phone in hand so the slightest vibration alerts them to the demand of the text. Young people and adults live hunched over their phones as they punch out cryptic messages oblivious to their surroundings. The attention span of most people has been reduced to 160 characters.
Now, while saying all of this, I am one who enjoys the technology and uses it. However, my life is not a Facebook expose’. There are people who have ruined their lives thinking Facebook is a good forum to vent their feelings on or show pictures that may be compromising. Really!? Cyperbullies? Turn your computer off.
At Christmas, all the kids came in with their newest tablets, electronic I mean, and they were enjoying all the new apps and movies. I commented to them that this could be the first Christmas when the family gets together and no one talks to each other because they are engrossed in their own little cyber world. Well, they did not continue and we had a great time, but that one moment when I walked into the room, it was everyone hunched over their device in the own world while all were around.
“Techiness” is fun but not at the expense of human interaction, I mean a real human, flesh and blood. Avatars, screen names, fake personas, all are fantasies that mean a person never learns how to be anyone; they are adrift in a sea of zeros and ones.
The whole culture will have to re-discover the arts of human civility, privacy, diplomacy of conversation. The very fruit of the Holy Spirit is the essence of human interaction that appreciates and honors and builds the community.
As a church or Christianity, I think our challenge is a communal one. Will we continue to extol relationship where one faces the reality of sin, the reality of grace, and the transforming power of God? Can we use technologies in a way that is godly rather than ungodly. Each new thing comes to us in a fairly moral neutrality, but man perverts it and many times makes it’s use immoral.
The church is challenged to be a place where people can still relate human to human and human to God. We must not lose our way, lose focus, or fail to tell the age old story of redemption. We still have to touch people. The Gospel is not the cyber message; it is a message of human pathos as one human touches another with redemptive grace, making room for the Holy Spirit to bring new life through a new birth. |
posted Oct 13, 2011 9:15 AM by Bill Lewis
[
updated Oct 13, 2011 9:16 AM
]
“And the things that you have heard of me among many witnesses, the same commit to faithful men, who shall be able to teach others also.” 2 Timothy 2:2
At my age, there is a tension for the present and the future. You want to be a viable force and ministry, but you also want to have things in place for the next generation. My son, Bill and I were talking about this and he commented that what came to him one day was, “Do you want to be a Legend or leave a Legacy?”
For me that summed up what I have been observing for years. This holds true in the corporate world, the church, and even family. John Maxwell, well known writer on leadership, states that all things rise or fall with leadership. While there are numerous approaches to leadership, it still takes leadership for success.
While visiting Bill in Georgia, we toured some Civil War sites and a study of that war shows the importance of leadership. Some generals were great leaders and others were not. The war would have lasted only a few weeks or months if the North had the quality of leadership that the South had.
Leadership is an innate quality of some, but has to be trained and cultivated. A leader can develop through trial and error at the expense of his followers, or he can be trained by those who have experience and allow the innate qualities to surface at an accelerated pace.
However, observation shows there are two kinds of leaders, those who want to be legends and those who want to leave a legacy.
The Legend leads with the iron fist of his or her qualities. Often the legend is brutal in execution of goals. The legend wants no challenges from subordinates since he has no peers. A legend can be extremely successful. Henry Ford was known for his invention and his temper. He single handedly destroyed a car on the line with a sledge hammer because it was not what he wanted; although the public was crying for it.
The legend does not prepare for the future since no one would be good enough, and somehow the legend thinks he will go on forever. His goal is to make everyone miss him when he is gone and the company, church, or family will just have to suffer his absence. It is the cowboy riding off into the sunset with Happy Trails playing in the background.
Leaving a legacy is a different story. The one who chooses to leave a legacy is intimately concerned with the future of the company, the church, the family. Leaving a legacy takes diligence, forethought, and planning. We all have a limited time on this earth. What can we do to make sure that the work we have done adds to the long term goal of the Kingdom?
Leaving a legacy requires identifying next generation potential. The potential is in people, not things. Who are the potential leaders? Who has been called of God? Who has those latent qualities to lead people? Whose character lends itself to integrity?
Legacy requires training those with the potential and giving them opportunity to lead in some subordinate role. However, the goal is to provide seamless leadership transitions for the sake of the company, church, or family.
The legacy maker is interested in people as well as the product or bottom line on a spreadsheet. While we want success as leaders, there is no success in doing well, dying, and having no one prepared to lead on.
Many of the churches I have observed are legend builders. There is no succession plan in place. Some of these churches will be one generation wonders. Some have already diminished or folded or are repositories of older folks with no young people around.
The Bible expressly tells leaders to train, entrust, and leave a legacy. Jesus’ ministry was not only teaching, preaching, and ministry of wonders, but it was full of next generation preparation. It was frustrating at times, evoking disappointment in them that they were not catching on, but continuing forward he moved.
You see, if there is no preparation for the next generation, they lose hope. Their gifts press them as did ours. My gifts still press me. Retirement is not the option for me since the gifts would continue to press me. I cannot imagine walking away and saying I am done with the kind of fire still burning within. But I also know how it is as a young person with a fire burning within. Legends drive all that talent away from themselves because of insecurity, or refusing to make room for the younger talent, or just the fear of competition that someone might have a better idea and ruin their legend status. Many churches have lost the cream of the crop to other works because of the legend mentality.
God wants us to leave legacies of good leaders. To be remembered as a good leader is great, but to be remembered as a leader who invested and trained is better. |
posted Sep 29, 2011 1:01 PM by Bill Lewis
Randy Ku tz has joined the ATMi Board of Directors. He is on the pastoral staff at Foundation Stone Christian Church in
Toledo, Ohio. His wife is Jennifer. Randy is one of the sons of Bob Kutz who was on staff at FSCC and a long time friend and member of ATM. Randy joins Roger Pugh, Jason King, and Bill Lewis on the directorship.
|
posted Sep 6, 2011 3:34 PM by Steve Highlander
ATMi Is sporting a new web site. The redesigned site is meant to be more infomrative and easier to manage, meaning that we can provide more resources and up-to-date information for our freinds and associates. You can subscribe to the news feature and the leader's blog and get posts in your E-mail so you don't miss out. |
|